Pokémon Game Reviews by Our Readers

Pokémon Dungeon readers have been reviewing the games since the early days, from the original Red and Blue to Sun and Moon and the spin-offs in between. Every reader review is here with the reviewer’s own score out of 10: pick a game to see only its reviews, or narrow the list by system and score. For the facts, the history and what the critics thought, see the game pages in our Games section.

48 reader reviews of 31 games · average score 7.9

Write a review Join for free

Reader reviews of

Pokémon FireRed & LeafGreen

Game Boy Advance · 2004 · 3 reviews · average 8.7/10

Review this game Game page →All games →

3 reviews Clear filters

Game Boy Advance

Pokémon FireRed review

One of the best Pokémon RPG's of all time.

by James Burton · 18 Aug 2017 · 6 min read

10Outstanding

Game Boy Advance

Pokémon LeafGreen review

Where the leaves are green

by nastynate3118 · 18 Aug 2017 · 8 min read

8Great

Game Boy Advance

Pokémon FireRed review

Hearts on Fire

by nastynate3118 · 18 Aug 2017 · 8 min read

8Great

Write a review

Played a Pokémon game? Members can review any game we have a page for, score it out of 10 and add a few screenshots. A moderator reads every review before it goes up.

Write a review

Highest rated games

Pokémon Ruby & Sapphire2 reviews9.5/10
Pokémon Red & Blue5 reviews9.4/10
Pokémon HeartGold & SoulSilver4 reviews9/10
Pokémon FireRed & LeafGreen3 reviews8.7/10
Pokémon Mystery Dungeon: Red & Blue Rescue Team2 reviews8.5/10

How our scores work

Every review is written by a Pokémon Dungeon reader or member, who scores the game out of 10. Half points are allowed.

10Outstanding A new favourite: one of the best Pokémon games there is.
9Excellent Superb, with only the smallest niggles.
8Great A great game you’d happily recommend.
7Good Good fun, with a few rough edges.
6Decent Worth a go for fans, but it has clear flaws.
5Mixed As much bad as good.
4Poor Hard to recommend.
1–3Bad Best avoided.

About Pokemon Dungeon

Explore

Follow Us